Comments on: Did Panda Kill SEO Copywriting? https://seocopywriting.com/did-panda-kill-seo-copywriting/ SEO Copywriting Training and Content Writing Tips Mon, 18 Mar 2019 21:49:00 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.5.2 By: 10 Hottest SEO Copywriting Posts of 2011 https://seocopywriting.com/did-panda-kill-seo-copywriting/#comment-233257 Mon, 18 Mar 2019 21:49:00 +0000 http://www.seocopywriting.com/?p=7486#comment-233257 […] Did Panda kill SEO copywriting?  Did Google’s Panda update mean the death of SEO copywriting? Not just “no” but […]

]]>
By: Heather https://seocopywriting.com/did-panda-kill-seo-copywriting/#comment-5662 Mon, 11 Jul 2011 14:56:29 +0000 http://www.seocopywriting.com/?p=7486#comment-5662 In reply to Scott.

Fantastic! I’m glad you enjoyed the blog! :)

]]>
By: Scott https://seocopywriting.com/did-panda-kill-seo-copywriting/#comment-5661 Sat, 09 Jul 2011 09:48:12 +0000 http://www.seocopywriting.com/?p=7486#comment-5661 First time here – Useful information – I most definitely will be back.

]]>
By: Heather https://seocopywriting.com/did-panda-kill-seo-copywriting/#comment-5660 Tue, 05 Jul 2011 22:56:52 +0000 http://www.seocopywriting.com/?p=7486#comment-5660 In reply to Graham.

Hi Graham!

Wow, it wasn’t too long ago when there were NO content shops exhibiting at a conference (at least during Search Engine Strategies.) I’d say that SEO content providers have come a long way…but I also know what kinds of companies are out there. :) Hopefully, at least one of them exhibiting *was* a solid white hat provider.

Oddly, I have written content about cement (assuming cement pavers qualifies!) It was a…challenge…but the client liked the articles (and I did too!) :)

Thanks for your post.

]]>
By: Heather https://seocopywriting.com/did-panda-kill-seo-copywriting/#comment-5659 Tue, 05 Jul 2011 22:47:22 +0000 http://www.seocopywriting.com/?p=7486#comment-5659 In reply to Vanessa.

Hi Vanessa!

You’re exactly right – solid content that’s SEO AND conversion optimized is still the way to go. Congrats that none of your clients were attacked by the big, hungry Panda. That definitely shows that you’re doing something right. :)

Thanks for your comment!

]]>
By: Graham https://seocopywriting.com/did-panda-kill-seo-copywriting/#comment-5658 Tue, 05 Jul 2011 21:59:19 +0000 http://www.seocopywriting.com/?p=7486#comment-5658 I am in the UK. I went to two Internet marketing exhibitions recently and there were plenty of companies pushing SEO optimised content creation and linkback services. All said that they were 100% white hat, honest, quality focused and could produce original content. All dismissed panda as having no effect on their customers. 7 SEO companies at one show claimed to be number 1 (or 2) in SEO and related services in the country ! Sadly the industry is still full of SnakE Oil purveyors. If you need to keep your sites alive and you don’t have the time, writing skills or knowledge to write fantastic articles that Google will love then you have to outsource the task. Finding good copywriters is like panning for gold and likely to throw up fools gold more often than 24kt gold. I challenged one company to write 15 compelling articles about cement (or drainage) that Google will love … I’m still waiting for the quote.

]]>
By: Vanessa https://seocopywriting.com/did-panda-kill-seo-copywriting/#comment-5657 Tue, 05 Jul 2011 19:15:34 +0000 http://www.seocopywriting.com/?p=7486#comment-5657 Thank you for helping to unravel the Panda-riddle. It seems, the more I read, that solid content that is SEO- and conversion-optimized is still the way to go.

I haven’t noticed it affecting my clients negatively and I love the challenge to continue developing my strategist skills for a better user experience.

Thanks again.

]]>
By: Heather https://seocopywriting.com/did-panda-kill-seo-copywriting/#comment-5656 Tue, 05 Jul 2011 15:02:30 +0000 http://www.seocopywriting.com/?p=7486#comment-5656 In reply to Terry Van Horne.

Terry-

FANTASTIC insight from one of the industry’s oldest (and best) SEOs. Thank you!:)

]]>
By: Terry Van Horne https://seocopywriting.com/did-panda-kill-seo-copywriting/#comment-5655 Sun, 03 Jul 2011 15:39:25 +0000 http://www.seocopywriting.com/?p=7486#comment-5655 Heather, truth be told I think Rand’s advice is easily misconstrued. Mainly cuz I see some of the types of content that people says don’t work… still working and well. However, if you’re in the payday loan category of those sites you see:

A: In general the tecghnique was overused with too narrow of focus, that, I agree seems an element of the algo

B: this is not a penalty in any sense of the word! It is simply an algo to make the techniques associated with some content type less valuable (likely partly manual and partly algorithmic). Penalty is often misused in our industry. If Google decides certain content is less valuable than thought… Google is not penalizing you… your expectations of the technique were not meant! There’s a difference and your judgement about content will improve if you don’t see these as penalties but a shift in value. Those who call them penalties need to see a site that gets penalized… panda though big… is nothing in comparison

C: if you look at the article archives in particular you see the heaviest hits are to the cats described above. ie inordinate amount of content with very narrow keyword focus.

I have spent a lot of time reviewing Panda with a lot of people asking me to review their site thinking they were hit. Many times I can’t see it directly on the site but you look at the off site work and well a lot of times it’s collateral damage from the sites linking to them sending much less value/link equity or as some may call it authority/PR.

BTW seen lots of people add images, comments, videos etc. I’d say it’s hardly a fix or that those elements are required for Google to like your page, people definitely but Google IMO, could care less!

In 16/7 years I’ve learned one thing that I always remnind myself going into a project… all sites and businesses are unique… your campaigns and strategy should be based on that rather than some cookie cutter solution like spinning articles and some magic formula that google likes to see in a page. #JusSayin

]]>
By: Heather https://seocopywriting.com/did-panda-kill-seo-copywriting/#comment-5654 Fri, 01 Jul 2011 17:29:33 +0000 http://www.seocopywriting.com/?p=7486#comment-5654 Thanks, Sarah! Glad that you enjoyed the post! ;)

]]>